What Does Isaiah 51:19 Mean?

These two have come to you. Who will grieve for you? Ruin and breaking, famine and sword. By whom shall I comfort you?
Isaiah 51:19 · SDV
Key words are shown with the Hebrew or Greek and what each word meant.

שְׁתַּ֤יִם הֵ֙נָּה֙ קֹֽרְאֹתַ֔יִךְ מִ֖י יָנ֣וּד לָ֑ךְ הַשֹּׁ֧ד וְהַשֶּׁ֛בֶרbreakingH7667 וְהָרָעָ֥ב וְהַחֶ֖רֶב מִ֥י אֲנַחֲמֵֽךְ׃

Shetayim hena koreotayikh mi yanud lakh hashod vehashever veharaav vehacherev mi anachamekh.

Selah Decoded Version The Selah Decoded Version renders what the Hebrew and Greek words meant to the people who first heard them.

This verse in the King James

King James wording
These two things are come unto thee; who shall be sorry for thee? desolation, and destruction, and the famine, and the sword: by whom shall I comfort thee?

The LORD names the double devastation that has fallen on Jerusalem, ravaging and shattering from without, hunger and blade from within, and asks who is left to sway in grief beside her and through whom he could console her, a question asked by the one who has already called himself her consoler.

This is the inner city after the cup is drained: devastation has come at it from outside and from within, and no one is left standing beside it. The verse does not hurry past the emptiness. It counts the losses, then asks twice who could meet them, and the one asking is the LORD himself. In the passage around it he has just said he is the one who does this work, and he is about to take the cup out of her hand. The question is not looking for a helper. It clears every other candidate away until only the asker remains.

WHAT THIS UNDOES

This undoes the belief that solace has to come from someone standing near enough and large enough to match the loss, when the voice asking who could console is the very one who has promised to.

נָחַם

nâcham

IN THIS VERSE

comfort

GROWS FROM

נ-ח-ם

The root pictures a deep sigh, the body letting out its grief, and then the comfort that follows.

“comfort” renders nacham, the deep sigh in which the body lets its grief out and ease follows. Here the LORD speaks the verb in the first person and asks by whom he could do it. Only a few lines earlier he names himself as the one who does exactly this, so the question already holds its own answer.

ALSO GROWS

nôcham: regret, relenting

נֹחַם

Nocham is the relenting side of the same deep sigh, a change of heart. In this chapter the sigh that consoles Jerusalem is also the moment the LORD turns from the cup of his rage and takes it out of her hand.

More roots ›

נוּד

nûwd

IN THIS VERSE

grieve for you

GROWS FROM

נ-ו-ד

The root means to sway or move to and fro, and by extension to wander.

“grieve” renders nud, to sway to and fro. It is the slow shaking of the head over someone else’s loss, a body moving in time with another’s grief. The verse asks who will make that motion for her, and the silence after the question is the answer.

ALSO GROWS

mânôwd: a derisive nod or toss of the head

מָנוֹד

Manod is the same swaying motion turned to scorn, the head tossed in mockery. The movement that could have kept her company becomes a jeer in other mouths, and the verse finds no one making it in sympathy.

שֶׁבֶר

sheber

IN THIS VERSE

breaking

GROWS FROM

ש-ב-ר

The root describes splitting something open or breaking it apart.

“Ruin” renders sheber, a splitting open, a fracture. Beside the ravaging that strips a place bare from outside, sheber is the break that runs through the thing itself. The verse holds it as pure loss and does not soften it. ⁨שֶׁבֶר⁩ (sheber) and ⁨מִשְׁבֵּר⁩ (mishbêr) come from a single root.

ALSO GROWS

mishbêr: the place where a baby breaks forth

מִשְׁבֵּר

Mishber is the opening through which a child breaks forth at birth. The city that bore and raised sons now has none to take her hand, and the word for her fracture also names the place where new life comes through.

When every human source of solace has gone missing, the lament stops looking sideways and its question is left open toward God alone.

Reproach has broken my heart, and I am frail. I wait for one to take pity, and there is none. I wait for comforters, and I find none.
Psalm 69:20 · SDVThe singer says “I wait for comforters”, and the very next line finds the place empty, the same emptiness this verse counts out.
So I turn back, and I see all the oppressions that are done under the sun. And behold, the tears of the oppressed, and no one to comfort them. And strength comes from the hand of their oppressors, and no one to comfort them.
Ecclesiastes 4:1 · SDVThe observer twice finds the oppressed with “no one to comfort them”, repeating the absence the way this verse repeats its questions.
And it will come to pass that all who see you will flee from you, and say, Nineveh is ravaged; who will mourn for her? From where will I seek comforters for you?
Nahum 3:7 · SDVOver Nineveh, the city that ravaged others, the onlookers ask “who will mourn for her” and where solace could be found, so the same empty circle closes around the oppressor too.
What shall I bring to witness for you? What shall I make equal to you, O daughter of Jerusalem? What shall I set in line beside you, that I may comfort you, O virgin daughter of Zion? For your breach is great as the sea. Who can heal you?
Lamentations 2:13 · SDV

The same grief turns toward the same city. The poet searches for anything to set beside Jerusalem so that solace could come, and then says “For your breach is great as the sea”. Both verses ask who could meet a fracture this wide and both leave the question open, but in Isaiah the one asking is the LORD, who has already named himself as the one who meets it.

Read the Selah Decoded Version, translated from the Hebrew and Greek.

In the app, any verse can be read the way you just read this one.

Get Selah

Selah is an app for iPhone and Android that decodes the Bible, word by word.

Does something in this reading look wrong? Tell us

Isaiah 51:19 Meaning